I was a Good Samaritan
I gave $20 to a stranger on Friday night. I happened to not be in a hurry, so I decided to hear him out on why he needed money for the bus. The last time this happened was in the bus station. Guy showed me $12 and said he just needed $8 more to get a ticket. So I said, OK, I don't have any cash, but you give me the $12, and let's go to the ticket booth and I'll put your ticket on my credit card. Guy didn't expect that, but worked out in his head that it didn't end with him having my cash, so he backed out. Obvious fraud. So I was expecting the same thing. This guy looked pretty clean-shaven and clothes were clean, so I stopped. He had a bus ticket. He had ID. His ticket was in his name, leaving Cleveland the night before. He had missed his bus. He said he was discharged from the Army for mental issues. He had his military ID and a huge bag of prescription meds. He said there was a $15 fee to transfer his ticket. I called Greyhound. He was right about the fee. He said he was going to a mental institute in Michigan. I said that was a good idea. He said he had been asking for help all day and everyone passed him by, including a Pharisee and a Teacher of the Law. I said that was too bad, maybe they were in a hurry to get to a prayer meeting. I said I would call and put his ticket on my credit card. He seemed enthusiastic. I was sold. I couldn't get through to the ticket agent, so I took him to the ATM and gave him the $20. I felt great! $20 was no great loss for me, but was a huge help for him. My satisfaction was entirely vicarious. I imagined him sitting on the bus, taking his mental disturbances out of Cleveland and to a safe place.
Some strange coincidences coincided to allow this fateful meeting.
1. My friend had just texted me to say he would be late, so I was willing to give this guy 30 seconds.
2. I was out of cash, and already planning to stop at an ATM.
3. His name was Robert.
Now, if this had happened when I was a believer, I would have seen the unmistakable hand of God at work, cleverly nudging things behind the scenes to unfold his Plan. And I think I could have been forgiven for thinking so. In any case, lacking any expectation of eternal reward for my kindness, I was forced to take all my reward in this life.
I then met up with my Catholic friend, and he asked why I would help someone, as an atheist. I explained that I didn't need God or eternal reward to feel good about being good. I explained that it was similar to the way sports fans take pleasure in the victories of their team, even though their loyalty is mostly arbitrary and they don't even know any of the people on the teams they cheer for, or have any reason to prefer their team over any other. In my case, I actually had an interaction with the person I derived vicarious satisfaction from, so it wasn't that hard to explain.
Some strange coincidences coincided to allow this fateful meeting.
1. My friend had just texted me to say he would be late, so I was willing to give this guy 30 seconds.
2. I was out of cash, and already planning to stop at an ATM.
3. His name was Robert.
Now, if this had happened when I was a believer, I would have seen the unmistakable hand of God at work, cleverly nudging things behind the scenes to unfold his Plan. And I think I could have been forgiven for thinking so. In any case, lacking any expectation of eternal reward for my kindness, I was forced to take all my reward in this life.
I then met up with my Catholic friend, and he asked why I would help someone, as an atheist. I explained that I didn't need God or eternal reward to feel good about being good. I explained that it was similar to the way sports fans take pleasure in the victories of their team, even though their loyalty is mostly arbitrary and they don't even know any of the people on the teams they cheer for, or have any reason to prefer their team over any other. In my case, I actually had an interaction with the person I derived vicarious satisfaction from, so it wasn't that hard to explain.
